The Electric Vs Pneumatic Debate 6554e921f1ac1

The electric vs. pneumatic debate

Nov. 15, 2023
Engineers are increasingly turning to electric systems in the quest for dependable accuracy

Electric multi-axis motion control systems by Norgren, a supplier of industrial pneumatic and electric motion control technologies, can handle distances ranging from 20 millimeters to 60 meters, offering flexibility for various applications.

In a recent episode of Automation World’s "Automation World Gets Your Questions Answered" podcast series, Anthony Leo from Norgren discussed the nuances between electric and pneumatic multi-axis motion control, offering insights crucial for controls engineers involved in building machinery for factories or plants.

Leo emphasized that multi-axis motion control, essential for tasks in a 3D plane like robotic pick and place or 3D printing, can be achieved through electric or pneumatic systems. Electric systems, akin to an etch-a-sketch, provide precision control, are easier to set up due to the absence of compressed air infrastructure, and demand less maintenance compared to pneumatic solutions. Weight and distance considerations are critical, with Leo stressing the need to appropriately size actuators based on calculations involving moment of inertia, especially when dealing with offset loads or pushing/pulling applications.

To learn more about the differences between electric and pneumatic motion control, read this article from Automation World.

Sponsored Recommendations

Engineers' Guide to AS-Interface

This guide provides all the information you'll need to know about AS-Interface in one easy-to-download pdf.

Why Electromechanical Actuators are Increasingly Replacing Hydraulic Systems

Are your heavy duty, automation applications tired of the mess, space, complexity, cost and other issues related to hydraulic systems? Converting to electromechanical linear actuators...

Validating and Optimizing Production Machinery

Join us on the path of efficient and digitalized production.

2025 State of Technology Report: Motors, Drives & Motion

Industrial motors account for a significant portion of energy costs. But reduced power spend isn’t the only advantage of using drives. And motor selection isn’t always...